| Seniors | Reserves | Under 18 | |||
| Year | Name | Name | Name | ||
| 1945 | William Field * | Jack Stevens | |||
| 1946 | Paddy Dean | Jack Stevens | |||
| Nick Muller Memorial Shield | |||
| 1947 | Alan Arnold | Ian Jones | S.Hodgson / J.Stevens |
| 1948 | Arthur Kenneally | Ron Clifford | S.Hodgson |
| 1949 | Ronald Clifford* | Allan Wilson | Trevor Cunningham |
| 1950 | Alan Arnold | Keith Barclay | Donald O'Hara |
| 1951 | Clive Waugh | Francis Buckley | Brian Kidd |
| 1952 | Jack Dean | Kevin Harrington | Brian Kidd |
| 1953 | Neil Tompkins | Kevin Harrington | P.West |
| 1954 | Ian Quick | Robert Smith | William Frost |
| 1955 | Alan Arnold | Ray Bews | Robert Cunningham |
| 1956 | Noel Robertson | Trevor Cunningham | Lance Collins |
| 1957 | Ronald Clifford | Brian Fort / Dale Jennings | Peter Trebilcock |
| 1958 | Rodney West | Dale Jennings | Peter Menzies |
| 1959 | Clive Waugh | Don Ricketts | Ross Allen |
| 1960 | Doug Jones | Noel Brown | Allan McDonald |
| 1961 | Doug Jones | Ron Ryder | Peter Keys |
| 1962 | Tom Hughes | Des Walsh | Peter Keys |
| 1963 | Doug Jones | Harold Watson | Graham Willis |
| 1964 | Peter Keys | Jack Dean | Alex Jankiewicz |
| 1965 | Peter Keys | John Paterson | F.Bein |
| 1966 | Peter Keys | Gary Tither | Jamie Gillies / Richard Urbanksi |
| 1967 | Peter Manorek | Barry Straughan | Alex Andjelkovic / Ian Chambers |
| 1968 | Kevin Dent | John Igual | Greg Moore / Richard Urbanski |
| David Willis Memorial Trophy | |||
| 1964 | Peter Keys | Jack Dean | Alex Jankiewicz* |
| 1965 | Peter Keys | John Paterson | F.Bein |
| 1966 | Peter Keys | Gary Tither | Jamie Gillies / Richard Urbanski |
| 1967 | Peter Manorek | Gbarry Straughan | Alex Andjelkovic / Ian Chambers |
| 1968 | Kevin Dent | John Igual | Greg Moore / Richard Urbanski |
| 1969 | Ian Room | David Willis | John Anderson |
| 1970 | Peter Keys | Alby Weigard | Wayne Moore |
| 1971 | Gordan Hynes | Ron Willis | Wayne Moore |
| 1972 | Gordon Hynes | Ron Willis* | John Turner |
| 1973 | Kevin Dent | Ron Willis* | G Lubke |
| 1974 | Denis Wilkie / Kevin Dent* | Ron Willis* | Steven Hardman |
| 1975 | Kevin Dent | David Willis | Team Disbanded |
| Lance Collins Perpetual Trophy | |||
| 1976 | Kevin Dent | Paul Cameron | Shaun Ryder |
| 1977 | Steve Dragicevic | Gary Battye | Daryl Jones |
| 1978 | Ken Rigg | David Willis | Wayne Collins U17 |
| Graham Willis Perpetual Trophy | |||
| 1979 | Alex Andjelkovic | Ron Willis | Stuart Hardman |
| 1980 | Daryl Colenso | Brian Hodgkins | Greg Barber |
| 1981 | Garry Birch | Hedley Duhau | Neil Alford |
| 1982 | Brendan Christensen | Russell Bellears | Greg Barber |
| 1983 | Neil Alford | Brian Hodgkins | Stuart Perry |
| 1984 | Garry Birch | Shane O'Keefe | |
| 1985 | Steve Dragicevic | Jeff Cameron | Martin Widdison |
| 1986 | Stuart Hardman | Russell Bellears | |
| 1987 | Terry Egberts | Ken Cahill | Dominic Memoli |
| 1988 | Tim Schwennesen | Gerry Dudley | Robert Williams |
| 1989 | Neil Alford | Neil Cromer* | |
| 1990 | Tim Schwennesen / Craig Eaves | Garry Birch | |
| 1991 | Tim Schwennesen | Garry Birch | |
| 1992 | Daryl Jones | Craig Cook* | |
| 1993 | Simon Vak / Ange Skoko | Garry Birch | Stuart Mahoney |
| 1994 | Daryl Jones* | Steven Smilovic | David Tarjani |
| 1995 | Daryl Jones | Dean Hynes / Wayne Yeatman* | Jamie Hutchinson |
| 1996 | Neil Alford | Jeff Mahoney | Troy Elzinga |
| 1997 | Mark Burns | Christian Owens | Mark Walsh / Brendan Cole* |
| 1998 | James Cummings / Daryl Jones* | Scott Parker | Matthew Armstrong / Brendan Cole* |
| 1999 | Ray Robertson | Adam Walsh | R.Brokenshire / Brendan Kennedy |
| 2000 | Russell Hearn | Matthew Weston | Rhys Brokenshire* |
| 2001 | Corey Lockwood | Kane Harrington | Tony Walsh |
| 2002 | Jason Rathje | Kane Harrington* | Tony Walsh / Sam Hall |
| 2003 | Andrew Ferguson | Ray Robertson | Tony Walsh |
| 2004 | Jamie Weise | Adam Benson | Tony Walsh |
| 2005 | Leigh Hardman* | Chris Fitzsimmons / Brendan Kennedy | Nathan Peoples |
| 2006 | Derek Fitzsimmons | Justin Hesslewood | Jarrod Bryant |
| 2007 | Darren Mathisen | Justin Hesslewood* | Braydee Watts |
| 2008 | Derek Fitzsimmons | Jason Habib | Braydee Watts* |
| 2009 | Braydee Watts | Matthew Weise | Josh Landsbury-Lowe |
| 2010 | Derek Fitzsimmons | Dion Arnol | Alex Perry |
| 2011 | Derek Fitzsimmons | Aaron Jervies | Darcy Eales* |
| 2012 | Derek Fitzsimmons | Tom Karacsay | Jake Balaki |
| 2013 | Derek Fitzsimmons | Mark Paramonov | Adam Heaver |
| 2014 | PJ DiSanto | Scott McKnight | Charlie Farrell |
| 2015 | James Chandler / Jamie Pitman* | Luke Schwennesen | Lachie Hayes |
| 2016 | PJ DiSanto | Andrew Fergusson / Toby Ryan | Thomas Schwennesen |
| 2017 | Derek Fitzsimmons | Shannon Benson | Thomas Schwennesen |
| 2018 | Daniel Kee | ||
| 2019 | Jimmy Vanderklay | ||
| 2020 | Corona Virus | ||
| 2021 | Thomas Schwennesen | ||
| 2022 | Mitch Habib | Daniel Andrews | |
